Planning a Small Wedding in Ohio? Real Experience from Real Couples!
There's something special about hindsight. When I ask couples months or years after their wedding what they wish they'd known beforehand, their answers are always illuminating. These insights don't come from wedding blogs or magazines, they come from real experience, and they're invaluable.
Recently, I reached out to couples who've tied the knot to ask a simple question: "What's one thing you wish you'd known before your wedding day?" The responses ranged from practical advice to emotional wisdom, and I want to share what I learned because these insights could transform your planning experience.
Why Real Couples Recommend Hiring Wedding Professionals
This theme came up again and again, and it's worth highlighting at the start: hiring wedding professionals, particularly a day-of coordinator or wedding planner, is worth every penny.
One couple emphasized this point strongly: hiring wedding professionals really does reduce stress and regrets. When you're planning an intimate wedding, you might think you can handle everything yourself. After all, it's only 30 people, right? How complicated could it be?
But here's what these couples learned: even with a small guest count, there are countless details to manage on the wedding day. Someone needs to cue the music, direct vendors, handle timeline adjustments, fix the boutonniere that fell off, find the missing lighter for the candles, and coordinate the grand exit. You don't want that someone to be you, your partner, or your mom.
How to Choose a Wedding Planner for an Intimate Celebration
When choosing a planner or day-of coordinator for your intimate wedding, several couples offered guidance:
Look for someone who truly understands micro weddings. Not all planners do. Some are used to large productions and may not know how to create the right flow for an intimate celebration. Ask potential planners about their experience with smaller weddings specifically.
Find someone who can be both organized and flexible. With fewer people and less rigid structure, intimate weddings sometimes call for spontaneous moments. You want a coordinator who can pivot gracefully when the schedule shifts or an opportunity arises to extend cocktail hour because everyone's having such a great time.
Choose someone who will be a sounding board during planning. The best coordinators don't just show up on wedding day, they help you think through decisions during the planning process. They've seen what works and what doesn't, and they can save you from costly mistakes or regrettable choices.
Trust your gut on personality fit. This person will be by your side during one of the most important days of your life. You should feel comfortable with them, trust them, and genuinely like them.
The Surprises That Turned Out Fine
One of my favorite questions to ask couples is: "What were you stressing about that turned out to be totally fine?"
The answers are remarkably consistent and reassuring:
The Weather So many couples obsess over weather, especially for outdoor weddings. Yes, weather matters, but couples who've been through it emphasize that your vendors have seen it all and have backup plans. That rain you were dreading? It often creates some of the most romantic, memorable photos. The heat you worried about? Your venue has fans, and your guests will be fine.
One couple shared a memorable story: they'd been watching the weather forecast obsessively for weeks, convinced their outdoor ceremony would be ruined. The morning of the wedding, it poured rain. They had to move everything inside, which they'd initially been devastated about. But looking back, they said the cozy indoor ceremony was even more intimate and special than the outdoor version would have been. Plus, the sun came out right before photos, and they got stunning images with dramatic clouds and fresh, rain-washed landscapes.
Guest Reactions to Non-Traditional Choices Many couples worried about guest reactions to unconventional choices: an afternoon wedding instead of evening, a Friday celebration instead of Saturday, a casual backyard vibe instead of formal ballroom, or skipping certain traditions altogether.
Almost universally, couples reported that their guests didn't care about these things at all. In fact, guests often appreciated the unique touches that made the wedding feel personal and authentic. The Friday morning brunch wedding? Guests loved starting their weekend with a celebration. The decision to skip the bouquet toss and garter removal? Nobody missed them.
DIY Projects Not Being Perfect Couples who took on DIY elements often stressed about them being "perfect." But on the actual wedding day, nobody noticed if the hand-lettered signs weren't quite straight or the centerpieces weren't identical. Guests were there for the couple, not to inspect the décor.
The Things That Actually Mattered
While couples stressed about details that turned out to be unimportant, they also reflected on what actually made a difference:
Quality Time with Guests Multiple couples wished they'd known how quickly the day would go by and how important it would be to build in time to actually talk with their guests. With an intimate wedding, you have the opportunity to have real conversations with everyone present. But you need to plan for this.
Some suggestions that came up:
Build buffer time into your timeline
Consider a longer cocktail hour where you can circulate
Skip super long photo sessions that take you away from guests
Have your photographer capture candid moments rather than endless posed group shots
Consider a pre-wedding welcome event if you're having out-of-town guests, so you're not trying to catch up with everyone on the wedding day itself
The Food Experience Several couples mentioned wishing they'd prioritized the food more highly. When guests look back on weddings, they remember whether the food was memorable or just... there. With a smaller guest count, you can afford to invest more per person in the culinary experience.
One couple said if they could do it over, they'd skip some of the décor elements and put that money toward a better caterer. Another mentioned that their decision to hire a chef who created a custom menu was the thing their guests still talk about years later.
The Photographer's Role Almost every couple emphasized how important their photographer was, not just in terms of the final images, but in terms of the actual wedding day experience. A great photographer helps you feel relaxed, captures genuine moments, keeps things moving smoothly, and somehow manages to be everywhere without being intrusive.
One couple's advice: meet with your photographer in person before booking them if at all possible. Look at full wedding galleries, not just highlight reels. Talk about their approach and style. Make sure you genuinely like them as a person, because they'll be with you for the most intimate moments of your day.
See how these intimate details come to life…
The Unexpected Challenges
While most surprises were positive, couples also shared a few challenges they wish they'd anticipated:
Family Dynamics Several couples mentioned that family dynamics became more intense in the lead-up to the wedding. Parents had opinions about the guest list, the venue, the menu, the timeline. Future in-laws weighed in on traditions and expectations.
The advice? Set boundaries early and kindly. It's your wedding, and while input from loved ones can be valuable, you and your partner get final say. Don't commit to things that don't align with your vision just to keep the peace, you'll regret it later.
The Guest List Creep Even with an intentionally intimate wedding, couples found themselves dealing with guest list pressure. "Can we invite my coworker?" "What about our neighbor?" "Shouldn't we include the kids?"
The couples who felt best about their final guest list were the ones who set clear criteria from the start and stuck to them. Maybe it's "only family and wedding party" or "only people we've spent time with in the last year" or "only adults." Whatever your rule, having it makes the hard conversations easier.
Still narrowing down your list? Use our Wedding Cost Calculator to see how an intimate guest count changes your budget.
Vendor Communication A few couples mentioned wishing they'd been more proactive about vendor communication as the wedding date approached. Following up on details, confirming timelines, double-checking deliveries, these aren't the fun parts of wedding planning, but they're crucial.
One couple suggested creating a master document with all vendor contact information, contracts, what's ordered, what's still needed, and key details. Share this with your coordinator or point person so someone besides you has the full picture.
The Memorable Moments (Good and Bad)
One couple shared a story that didn't go as planned: they'd booked an outdoor venue, and the day turned out to be unseasonably cold and windy. It wasn't fun during the event, but looking back, it became part of their story. Their guests still laugh about huddling together for warmth during the ceremony, and the photos of everyone wrapped in blankets during cocktail hour are some of their favorites.
The lesson? Not everything will go perfectly, and that's okay. The imperfect moments often become the most memorable and the most meaningful. Your wedding day isn't a performance to be executed flawlessly, it's the beginning of your marriage, and real life is beautifully imperfect.
The Emotional Preparation Nobody Talks About
Several couples mentioned wishing someone had prepared them for the emotional intensity of the wedding day, not just the ceremony itself, but the whole experience.
You might cry more than you expected. You might feel overwhelmed by the attention. You might have a moment of anxiety or doubt that has nothing to do with your relationship. You might feel the weight of all the people you love being in one room. You might grieve loved ones who aren't there.
All of this is normal, and it's helpful to know in advance that weddings are emotionally complex. Give yourself permission to feel whatever comes up, and don't judge yourself for having complicated emotions on a day that's "supposed" to be perfectly happy.
Practical Wisdom Worth Sharing
Beyond the big themes, couples offered specific practical tips:
Eat breakfast on your wedding day. You'll be too excited to feel hungry, but you need fuel. Have someone make sure you eat something substantial.
Put someone else in charge of your phone. You don't need to be checking texts or taking calls on your wedding day.
Build in private moments with your partner. Plan 10-15 minutes during the day to step away together, take a breath, and really be present with each other.
Tip your vendors generously if they go above and beyond. You'll remember their exceptional service long after you've forgotten about other expenses.
Have someone be the point person for family questions. Direct all "where should I stand?" and "when are we eating?" questions to your coordinator or designated helper, not to you.
Don't sweat the small stuff on the day itself. If something goes wrong, and something usually does, it probably won't matter in your memories.
Take a moment to look around and really see your guests. In the rush of the day, pause and observe everyone celebrating you. That image will stay with you forever.
What They'd Do Differently
When I asked couples what they'd change if they could do it over, here are the most common responses:
Spend less time on details that don't matter. So many hours spent debating napkin colors or welcome sign fonts, time they could have spent enjoying the engagement period.
Invest more in the things that last. Better photography, better videography, better food. These are what you'll have for years to come.
Stress less about other people's expectations. The people who love you will support your choices, and everyone else's opinion doesn't actually matter.
Be more present during the planning process. It's easy to get caught up in stress and logistics and forget to enjoy being engaged.
Say yes to help when it's offered. Pride or perfectionism shouldn't stop you from accepting assistance from people who genuinely want to support you.
The Best Advice: Focus on What Matters
If there's one overarching theme in all of these reflections, it's this: focus on what actually matters.
What matters is your commitment to your partner. What matters is being surrounded by people who love and support you. What matters is creating a celebration that feels authentic to who you are as a couple. What matters is how you'll remember the day years from now.
What doesn't matter? Whether your centerpieces are exactly as you imagined. Whether every detail goes according to plan. Whether you follow all the traditional wedding "rules." Whether your celebration looks like anyone else's.
The couples who had the best wedding experiences weren't the ones who executed a perfect event, they were the ones who stayed focused on why they were getting married in the first place and let everything else be secondary.
Moving Forward with Wisdom
As you plan your own wedding, I encourage you to learn from these couples' experiences. Hire good vendors and trust them. Don't sweat the small stuff. Invest in what matters. Set boundaries with kindness. Be present for the experience rather than just the execution.
At Cedar Bay Farm, we've had over 140 weddings since hosting them in 2021, and we've gathered a lot of wisdom about what makes for a truly wonderful celebration. We're always happy to share what we've learned and help couples avoid common pitfalls while focusing on what will make their day meaningful.
Your wedding day is just one day, but your marriage is a lifetime. Plan a celebration that honors that perspective, and you'll have no regrets, just beautiful memories and the beginning of your next adventure together.
Book a Private Tour of Cedar Bay Farm…